Main Menu



By: Christine Davidson

Print this Page


Auto Lease vs. Loan: Which Is Best for You?

Credit and Debt | Auto Buying


Statistics suggest that more people are leasing now than ever. As car prices increase and lease rates decrease, Americans (and millennials in particular) are opting to take on an auto lease rather than taking out a car loan. Auto leasing is a valid choice for some but may be the more expensive option for others. Before you settle on one option, consider the benefits and drawbacks as well as the overall costs of each.

Comparison of Leasing and Loaning


Auto loan

You’re always driving a new vehicle, which can improve the safety and enjoyment of traveling

Your vehicle will age as you pay on the loan, which may result in more costly maintenance

Because you don’t own the vehicle, you can’t alter it to fit your needs or your personality

The vehicle is yours, so you can personalize it as much as you like

Vehicles that were once out of your price range may be affordable by lease

Taking on an auto loan means purchasing a vehicle within your means

Repair and maintenance are often covered in the leasing agreement

You will be responsible for maintenance and repair over the life of your vehicle

Mileage limits can result in mileage charges at the end of the lease term

You don’t have to worry about mileage limits

You will be responsible for any undue wear and tear of the vehicle

You don’t have to pay a fee for wear and tear

Monthly payments are often lower than auto loan payments

Monthly payments can be higher than lease payments

Once you’ve paid off your lease, you can take on another lease but you have no equity in the vehicle you’ve been paying on

Once you’ve paid off your loan, you own the vehicle and can sell it or continue to drive it payment-free


Payment Structure and Finance Charges

Whether you take out a loan on a vehicle or opt to lease, your payments are based on the price of the vehicle. On a vehicle loan, you make monthly payments on the full price of the vehicle. As an example, a $24,000 car financed over a 36-month loan term at 2.25% APR would cost you $690.04 per month.*

With a lease, the vehicle is considered an asset, which reduces over time. Rather than paying on the full value of the vehicle, you pay on its depreciation (the amount of vehicle value you use up during the lease term). The dealership calculates your lease payment by determining the current value of the vehicle and subtracting the value it will likely have when the lease term ends (residual value). For example, the same $24,000 car mentioned above financed over a 36-month loan term at 2.25% APR, with a likely $6,000 residual value after a three-year lease (i.e., $18,000 as the starting cost), would cost $517.53 per month.*

Finance charges are the interest charges and other fees that come with borrowing money. Interest is the largest of these charges and both auto buyers and leasers must pay them. On a loan, interest is assessed on the entire price of the car and paid out over the term of the loan. With a lease agreement, you pay interest on the depreciation only.

It’s easy to assume that leasing is less expensive because the payments are lower. However, once you’ve paid off a car loan, you own the vehicle free and clear (which means you don’t have to make payments any longer) and you have equity in an asset that you can sell to make back a portion of your investment. Leases are different. You never “pay it off,” unless you decide to buy. If you do decide to purchase the vehicle, you will have to pay taxes and interest on the balance, which can cost more than a traditional auto loan would have cost.  

*The examples above are for illustrative purposes only and do not include tax, title, or other fees that may be associated with purchasing or leasing a vehicle.

 Calculate Loan and Lease Costs

So Which Is the Best Option for You? Leasing or Buying?

If you’re still not certain which option is best for you, here is a slightly different way to think about it.

You may want to lease your next vehicle if you…

  • Have a low monthly cash flow and can’t afford the higher loan payments
  • Don’t put a lot of miles on your vehicle
  • Don’t need or want to modify or personalize your vehicle
  • Don’t ride rough and will therefore return the car without any undue wear and tear
  • Only need the car for a short period of time (for example, you’re moving temporarily for work or visiting a foreign country)

You may want to finance your next vehicle with a loan if you...

  • Have adequate cash flow
  • Tend to drive a lot for work or fun
  • Use your vehicle to tote small children or animals, which could cause stains or other damage to the interior
  • Would like to build equity in your vehicle for future resale

One last thing to keep in mind is your credit score. The lower your credit score is, the more you will pay in interest charges and the higher your monthly payment will be, regardless of whether you lease or buy. Take the time to check your credit score and clean up any inaccuracies before shopping for a vehicle.

STOP! Don't shop for your next car without our Car Buying 101 guide to car shopping.


About Christine Davidson

Christine Davidson is the integrated lending administrator at VSECU. She has two children and lives with her husband in Northfield.